Set up a fair comparison
Buy similarly sized thighs for two dinners and use the same rub, pit temperature, and cooking method. Pick a single wood for each cook. Record the amount in a way you can repeat with your own equipment. In a pellet grill, note the pellet blend on the bag.
Taste before adding sauce
Try a bite of skin and a bite from the center while the meat is warm. Write three plain words about the flavor. For example, you might notice gentle smoke, sweetness, or a bitter finish. Also write down whether the fire was steady. That observation matters when two cooks taste unexpectedly different.
Make a decision for the next meal
Read both notes together. If the second dinner tasted more smoky and its fire also ran poorly, repeat it before blaming the wood. If both were pleasant, keep the wood you would choose for a mild chicken dinner and save the other for a richer sauce.

