Pork
Oak-smoked pulled pork
A bone-in pork shoulder with a dark pepper bark and a cider-vinegar finish. Wrap when the crust sets and save the juices for shredding.
Plan this cook
- On the smoker
- 6–10 hr
- Pit temperature
- 275°F / 135°C
- Smoking wood
- Oak
- Serves
- 10–12
At the smoker
20 min prep · 6–10 hr on the pit · 60 min rest
Trim and rub the shoulder
Trim loose flaps and reduce thick exterior fat to about ¼ inch (6 mm). Coat with mustard. Mix the pepper, salt, paprika, and garlic and pat over every side.
Look for The shoulder is roughly even in shape with the seasoning tucked into the seams.
Mine looks different
Keep the shoulder cold until the smoker is ready. A deep seam can stay intact for a bone-in cook.
Set up a long smoke
Bring the smoker to 275°F (135°C) with oak and indirect heat. Place the fat toward the hotter side. Insert a probe into the center of the thickest muscle, away from bone, and close the lid.
Look for The grate probe reads a steady cooking temperature and the meat probe sits in lean muscle.
Mine looks different
A pellet hopper or charcoal basket needs enough fuel for a long cook. Check it periodically without opening the cooking chamber.
Wait for the bark to set
Smoke until the crust is dark reddish brown and firmly attached. The internal temperature may linger around 150–170°F (66–77°C). When the bark holds, wrap the shoulder tightly in heavy foil and return it to the pit.
Look for A gentle touch leaves the bark on the meat. The outside feels dry even if the internal temperature has barely moved.
Mine looks different
A flat temperature during this stage is common. Check the pit temperature and probe position, then keep cooking. Reinspect a pale or soft crust before wrapping.
Check for tenderness
Begin probing through the foil around 195°F (91°C). Check several spots clear of the bone. Many shoulders soften near 200–205°F (93–96°C). Take it off when the thick muscles yield easily.
Look for The probe glides easily into several areas, including the thick center.
Mine looks different
If one area still grips the probe, close the wrap and continue in 15–20 minute intervals. A single hot pocket can give an early reading.
Rest, then pull
Set the wrapped shoulder in a rimmed pan. Rest for about 1 hour, monitoring that it stays at or above 140°F (60°C). Remove the bone, separate the meat with forks, and stir in the skimmed pan juices and cider vinegar to taste.
Look for The bone loosens with a gentle twist and the meat separates into moist strands.
Mine looks different
For a longer hold, use a warming oven and a probe to verify the meat stays at or above 140°F (60°C). Pull just before serving.
